Mystery Bay Farm

Mystery Bay Farm


Mystery Bay Farm is a small scale, family farm operating on five acres on Marrowstone Island. A WSDA certified Grade A Dairy, producing farmstead, goat milk cheeses and yogurt for general sale. (Farmstead means we make all of our cheeses and yogurt using only the milk of our animals.)

In addition to cheese and yogurt, Mystery Bay Farm offers educational farm tours and cheese making classes.


Our Products

Try our products. including: CHEVRE, FARMSTEAD YOGURT, Spring’s WHOLE MILK RICOTTA and Fall’s SPECIAL GOAT MILK CARAMEL SAUCE! Throughout the year taste the uniqueness that each season imparts care of various flavors and textures in each Mystery Bay Farm offering.  Every bite of Mystery Bay Farm fare offers a seasonal uniqueness; spring brings creaminess with the freshness of green grass, while fall walks us into winter with rich, almost double cream, balanced by a subtle tang.


Farm Tours, Milking and Production tour options are available. We milk 100% American Alpine dairy goats. They each have been raised on our farm and have names and distinct personalities! Try Mystery Bay Farm products throughout the year to see the uniqueness that each season imparts on the flavor and texture.



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *